Seen as Indian investor's gateway to AI play, what went wrong with Fractal Analytics IPO?

Synopsis Fractal Analytics debuted below issue price as muted retail demand and valuation concerns overshadowed its AI positioning. Despite institutional support, high multiples, volatile margins and IT sector weakness capped listing gains. Long-term prospects hinge on revenue consistency, attrition control and converting AI capabilities into scalable, recurring earnings growth over time. Fractal Analytics, widely billed as Indian investors' gateway to the artificial intelligence theme, made a subdued stock market debut on February 16, listing at Rs 876 on the NSE, a 2.7% discount to its issue price of Rs 900. The stock fell further in afternoon trade, trading nearly 5% below the offer price. The soft listing can be puzzling for a company positioned at the heart of one of the fastest-growing global sectors. Investor demand set the tone, as it was quite muted for the first few days, and the IPO only sailed through on the last day, thanks to institutional investors. The Rs 2,840 crore offer was subscribed 2.66 times overall, in which Qualified Institutional Buyers subscribed 4.18 times. However, the Non-Institutional Investor segment was subscribed to just 1.06 times and the retail portion only 1.03 times, reflecting limited enthusiasm outside institutional circles. The muted retail response proved significant on listing day. One of the main reasons for this, analysts say, is the age-old valuation concerns. At the upper price band of Rs 900, the stock was valued at a FY25 post-issue P/E multiple of 78.9x, according to SBI Securities. While revenue grew at an 18% CAGR between FY23 and FY25 and rose 20% year-on-year in the first half of FY26, profit growth and margins were less consistent. Live Events The company's profit after tax stood at Rs 220.6 crore in FY25, but historical earnings volatility and elevated attrition levels, at 16.3% in FY25 and 15.7% in the first half of FY26, added to investor caution. SBI Securities had assigned a neutral rating ahead of listing, stating that "considering the elevated valuation, we would like to track the performance of the company for a few quarters post listing." The broader market backdrop did not help either. IT stocks have corrected sharply in recent weeks amid concerns that generative AI tools could reduce demand for traditional outsourcing and analytics services. For a company marketed as an AI pure play, that paradox was again a mystery. It could also be that some analysts, like Lakshmishree, said that while AI represents a growth engine, it also introduces disruption risks, including the possibility of clients building more capabilities in-house. Ravi Singh, Chief Research Officer at Master Capital Services, said the weak opening was largely sentiment-driven. "The institutional segment showed interest, but retail participation was modest. In the current market environment, valuation discipline is very important," he said. Fractal operates in two major segments: Fractal.ai, which offers AI-driven services and products through its platform Cogentiq, and Fractal Alpha, which incubates independent AI businesses. The company counts marquee names such as Citibank, Costco, Franklin Templeton, Mars, Mondelez, Nestle and Philips among its clients, with the top ten customers contributing more than half of its revenue. Client stickiness has been strong, with an average tenure of more than eight years among its largest accounts. Singh said that from a long-term perspective, the company remains well-positioned to benefit from the global AI opportunity. Lakshmishree also highlighted the long-term structural theme but cautioned that rapid advances towards more autonomous AI systems could disrupt traditional analytics models. Even so, it noted that Fractal’s established niche and client relationships offer competitive strength. For short-term investors who entered purely for listing gains, the soft debut signals that immediate upside may be limited. However, for long-term investors with a higher risk appetite, the listing discount could offer a more reasonable entry point compared to IPO pricing, provided they are comfortable with near-term volatility, according to Singh. The key monitorables over the next few quarters will be revenue growth consistency, margin expansion, attrition trends and clarity on how much of its AI capability translates into scalable, recurring revenue. Investors will also watch whether large clients increase spending on AI transformation projects and whether Fractal can protect pricing in a rapidly evolving landscape. The global AI market is projected to reach $310 billion by FY30, offering a significant runway. Fractal's challenge will be converting that opportunity into predictable earnings growth at a valuation that justifies investor confidence. (Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times.) (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel) (What's moving Sensex and Nifty Track latest market news, stock tips, Budget 2025, Share Market on Budget 2025 and expert advice, on ETMarkets. Also, ETMarkets.com is now on Telegram. For fastest news alerts on financial markets, investment strategies and stocks alerts, subscribe to our Telegram feeds .) Subscribe to ET Prime and read the Economic Times ePaper Online.and Sensex Today. Top Trending Stocks: SBI Share Price, Axis Bank Share Price, HDFC Bank Share Price, Infosys Share Price, Wipro Share Price, NTPC Share Price ...moreless Why India’s steel ambitions are running into a scrap shortage Out, then in again: How AI put consulting back on IT’s hotlist How pension funds flow into equity ETFs skewing markets “Mere paas metric hai”: The valuation story most startups sell Stock Radar: Breakout from triangle formation pushes Indus Tower to record highs in February 2026; time to buy or book profits? Stock picks of the week: 5 stocks with consistent score improvement and upside potential of up to 41% 1 2 3