Traditional safe-haven assets such as US Treasuries , gold and the Japanese yen are becoming less reliable as portfolio hedges, with recent market selloffs exposing their vulnerabilities, according to a Reuters report.
In April 2025, US tariff concerns triggered an equity selloff, but Treasuries fell alongside stocks, pushing bond yields higher. A similar trend emerged after the US-Israeli war with Iran began on February 28, as rising oil prices fuelled inflation concerns. Gold also declined sharply in late October, touching a one-year low.
Steve Englander, global head of G10 FX research at Standard Chartered, said investors were running out of dependable safe-haven options.
US Treasuries remain attractive during conventional risk-off episodes but can struggle when inflation and expectations of Federal Reserve rate hikes dominate markets. Rising US debt, fiscal deficits and interest payments have also added to concerns about their defensive appeal.
Gold, meanwhile, offers greater protection over longer investment horizons but can experience sharp short-term declines. Investors may also sell the metal to meet margin calls during equity market turmoil, particularly after strong price rallies.
Currencies have their own limitations. The Swiss franc is expensive, the euro faces political and economic challenges, while the yen remains vulnerable to rising oil prices because of Japan's dependence on energy imports.
The US dollar continues to offer relative safety, liquidity and attractive yields, making it a preferred destination during periods of uncertainty.
Duke University finance professor Campbell Harvey said investors should diversify defensive portfolios across gold, Treasuries, commodities, inflation-protected bonds and active investment strategies. Quality-focused and trend-following strategies could also help limit losses during market downturns.
No single asset offers reliable protection in every crisis, making diversification increasingly important for investors.